之前我已經介紹了整個Horrible Histories系列,所以理論上不太需要另外介紹系列裡面的某幾本書。但是因為最近發生的一些事情,我覺得也該是時候拿這兩本書來說說了。
我的本科不是歷史系,但是也曾經自修會考西方歷史科(畢竟我媽是西史老師)加上在約克這個古城讀大學的時光,歷史對自己來講沒有那麼遙遠。
可是始終因為地理跟時光的差異,西方歷史還是會有一點距離感,學生覺得那邊的歷史只是一堆要硬生生吃下去考試時吐出來的知識也不是沒有原因的吧?對我來說,真正感受到一二戰的震撼,除了參觀波蘭的奧斯威辛集中營之外就是參觀曼徹斯特的戰爭博物館…..
還有這兩本書。
Horrible Histories系列的特點是用輕鬆幽默的手法去介紹歷史,讓小朋友對歷史有多點興趣。但是看過這麼多本系列作品之後,我敢說這兩本講述一二戰的書是系列中最正經的。
當然啦,正經不代表沉悶,作者的一貫風格在兩本書也不是看不到的。只是論內容來講,作者很清楚哪些時候適合搞笑,哪些時候要把笑臉收起來,有哪些界線是不能跳過去的。看這兩本書還是會笑,只是笑中絕對會有淚的。
另外兩本書跟英國戰爭博物館有一些共通點。大家都會講述一些一二戰時發生的大事沒錯,但是兩者的集中點都不是歌頌盟軍有多棒痛罵納粹有多邪惡,而是戰爭下的一般人。一些有血有肉,有自己的家庭生活工作夢想的普通老百姓。
約克城堡博物館的一戰展覽我有去看,整個展覽的設計是跟著幾位住在約克的平民在一戰爆發之後的經歷。我們在展覽中認識到他們在參軍前的生活跟參軍後的去向,很簡單地就把現代人跟當年的人連在一起,一戰的歷史也不再那麼抽象和難以代入。
同樣道理,戰爭博物館跟這兩本書有不少篇幅就是講述普通的平民跟軍人在一二戰時的設身經歷和生活方式,這時候大家感受到的不是勝利者在強調自己有多勇敢,而是戰爭的殘酷跟人們對和平的渴望。
兩本書中印象最深刻的,是Woeful Second World War中的一小段,當中是圖文並荗地講述一次針對某個小城鎮的轟炸。當時城鎮剛好有馬戲團來表演,大家都為了能夠短暫忘掉戰爭的恐怖而樂透了。然而在戰機的猛烈轟炸之下,小城鎮化為烈火,原本開心的歡笑聲也變成慘叫跟求救聲。
這時候大家的直覺就是,這是德軍在轟炸小城鎮對吧?
但是很抱歉,作者筆下的這個小城鎮其實在德國。而無情轟炸的劊子手,是英國皇家空軍。
歷史是由勝利者寫出來的,加上這系列本來是寫給小朋友看的,如果作者把這些事情省略掉不說也沒什麼好驚訝的。但是作者沒有這樣做。作者筆下的兩次戰爭不是單純的邪不能勝正,而是要強調戰爭中大家認定的"正方"也會幹出殘害無辜平民的事,"反方"的國家也是戰爭的受害者之一。戰爭有勝有敗,但是會有真正的贏家嗎?
一二戰的歷史除了日本侵華那一段之外大家也許會沒什麼感覺,但是對地球另一邊的人卻是心中的傷痕。所以真的,不要拿這種事情來亂開玩笑。這已經不只是國際觀的問題,而是很簡單的一種對歷史的尊重的問題。Horrible Histories的作者很清楚,我也希望大家也一樣那麼清楚。
Since I’ve already introduced the Horrible Histories series as a whole, arguably there is no need for me to focus on any particular books within the series. However, following the events happening these days, I figured that it’s about time to start talking about these two books.
My major isn’t history, but I did self-study CE-level world history (since my mom is a world history teacher herself). Combined with my university life in York, a town steeped in history, history isn’t quite as far away as I thought.
However, considering the physical and time differences, there’s still some distance between us and western history, and there’s a reason why some students view western history as nothing more than a bunch of facts to swallow up and spit out during exams. To me, the biggest shocks the two World Wars gave me was during my visits to the Auschwitz concentration camp and the Imperial War Museum in Manchester…
And these two books.
Horrible Histories is most iconic for its relaxed and humourous take on history, in a bid to get kids interested in history. But after reading so many books from the series, I daresay that these two books are the most serious of the lot.
Of course, being serious doesn’t mean being boring, and it’s still possible to find shades of the author’s usual style in those books. It’s just that when it comes to the contents, the author understands when to crack jokes, when to hold those smiles back, and which lines should not be crossed. You can still laugh when reading these books, but there will be tears mixed into it.
Moreoever, there are some similarities between those two books and the War Museum in the UK. Although both will describe the major events in the two World Wars, their focus isn’t about how great the Allies are or how horrible the Nazis are. Instead, they talk about ordinary people in the war. Just average joes with their own lives, families and dreams.
I’ve been to the World War 1 exhibition in York’s Castle Museum, and the whole exhibition is designed to follow the lives of several yorkshiremen after war broke out. We get to know more about their life before and during the war, and in a way the exhibition connected the people in the past and in the present. World War 1 is no longer as abstract and difficult to relate to as it used to be.
Similarly, the War Museum and the two books spend a lot of words talking about the life of ordinary people and ordinary soldiers under the war. What we see isn’t a winner emphasizing their bravery, but the terrors of war and hope for peace.
The most memorable part of those two books is one small section in “The Woeful Second World War", illustrating the bombing of a small town. Back then there was a travelling circus performing in the town, and people were overjoyed to forget about the war, even for a short moment. However, as the planes drop their bombs from above, the town was soon engulfed with flames, and what used to be laughter soon turned into screams of help.
At this point, you’d probably think this is a bombing from the Germans, right?
I’m sorry, but the town the author described was actually in Germany. Who did the bombings? The UK’s Royal Air Force.
History is written by the winners, and Horrible Histories is written for children, so it won’t be surprising if the author decided to omit this bit. But the author didn’t do so. Under the author’s pen, the two World Wars are not simple cases of “good will pervail over evil". During wartime, even the “good" side can murder innocents, and even the “bad" side can be victims as well. There are winners and losers in war, but is there a true “winner" in the end?
The two World Wars, aside from Japan’s invasion in China, may be something we don’t give much thought about. But to the people living in the other side of the globe, those wars are real scars in their hearts. So please, don’t joke about things like this lightly. It’s no longer just a matter of understanding the world, it’s also a matter of respecting history. The author of Horrible Histories understands this, and I hope everyone can do the same.